DONOVAN  RESERVE ← donovan.law
Section 1 of 12

Company & Jurisdiction

Establish the entity structure, formation state, company name, principal office, registered agent, and effective date.

HoldCo + OpCo is institutional standard for charging-order protection, lender SPE compliance, asset-protection segregation, and uniform state-law treatment across multi-state portfolios. The HoldCo (investor-facing) carries the membership classes, waterfall, and governance; the OpCo (single-member, owned 100% by HoldCo) holds the property and is the lender’s collateral. The Operating Agreement form fields below apply to the HoldCo; OpCo details are captured separately.

Delaware is the default for institutional multi-member structures. Strong statutory recognition of freedom of contract under 6 Del. C. § 18-1101(b); well-developed Chancery Court case law; broad ability to eliminate fiduciary duties under § 18-1101(c) (consult counsel before invoking).

Include the entity designator. Verify name availability with the relevant Secretary of State before filing.

Effective date of this Operating Agreement.

Section 2 of 12

Members

Define each Member of the Company. Members may be individuals, trusts, or entities. Class assignment and capital contribution amounts are configured per-Member after the membership classes are defined in Section 3.

Securities Compliance & Disclosure — Phase 4

Selects the Reg D level (or non-Reg-D treatment) and drives generation of the appropriate disclosure document package. Mirrors the four-level taxonomy used in the firm’s Deal Builder.

Level 0 — small operating-member JVs where membership interests do not constitute “securities” under Howey + Williamson v. Tucker. Generates a JV Securities Analysis Memo and enhanced Member Joinder. Level 1 — F&F-style 506(b) with accredited investors and limited (≤35) sophisticated non-accredited investors; no general solicitation; generates a Risk Disclosure Letter rather than full PPM. Level 2 — Sophisticated 506(b) with full PPM; same investor limits as Level 1 but with formal PPM disclosure. Level 3 — 506(c) accredited-only with general solicitation permitted; requires reasonable steps to verify accredited status under Rule 506(c)(2)(ii).

Section 3 of 12

Membership Classes

Define the classes of Membership Interest. Each Class has distinct economic and governance rights. Each Member is assigned to one or more Classes with specified Units and capital contribution.

Class structures supported. Each Class is independently configured for preferred return (rate, simple vs. compounded, cumulative vs. non-cumulative), capital call obligation, voting rights, distribution priority position in the waterfall, and liquidation priority. Profits Interest classes (carried interest) are recognized for § 83 / Rev. Proc. 93-27 safe-harbor treatment with appropriate language.

Member ↔ Class Assignments

Assign each Member to one or more Classes. For each assignment, specify the number of Units and the Capital Contribution attributable to that Class.

Section 4 of 12

Capital Contributions

Initial capital contributions are set per-Member-per-Class in Section 3. This section governs additional capital, capital calls, default remedies, and withdrawal restrictions.

Defines who can initiate an Additional Capital Contribution request.

Select all that apply; the Manager may invoke any combination at its discretion.

Section 5 of 12

Management & Governance

Designate the management structure, identify the Manager (if Manager-Managed), and specify Major Decisions requiring Member-level consent over and above Manager authority.

Manager-Managed is standard for institutional structures with passive investor Members. Board-Managed provides multi-Manager governance with director-style fiduciary structure.

If a Member, the Manager-Member retains a Member capital position separately from its Manager role.

Delaware permits broad elimination of fiduciary duties (except the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing) under § 18-1101(c). Common in sponsor-led structures where the Manager has competing investment interests.

Decisions requiring approval beyond Manager-level authority. Threshold defaults to Majority in Interest but can be elevated per item.

Manager Entity & Services — Optional, Phase 3a

If the Manager is a separate LLC (typical for sponsor-led structures), populate these fields to also generate the Manager Entity Operating Agreement and the Management Services Agreement between the Manager and the Company.

Section 6 of 12

Distributions / Waterfall

Configure the distribution waterfall. Distributions flow through the configured Tiers in sequence; each Tier completes before the next begins. Standard structures range from pro rata to full multi-tier IRR-hurdle waterfalls with sponsor catch-up and promote escalators.

Percentage of distributions to GP after LP receives preferred return, until GP has received its target % of total promote distributions.

Promote Tier Schedule — specify each promote tier after the catch-up. Each tier specifies the LP/GP split until an IRR hurdle is met, after which the next tier’s split applies.

If "Per positive capital accounts" is selected, allocations must be drafted to force economic deal into capital accounts (typical when using targeted allocations).

Section 7 of 12

Allocations — § 704(b)

Choose the allocation regime governing how income, gain, loss, and deduction are allocated among Members for tax purposes. Two principal regimes are supported: (i) Substantial Economic Effect (PIPCA) under Reg. § 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(b), and (ii) Targeted Capital Accounts (forced allocations to reach the economic deal). Regulatory safe-harbor allocations apply under either regime.

Targeted Capital Accounts is the prevailing institutional approach: allocations are made to ensure that, on a hypothetical liquidation at book values, each Member’s Capital Account equals the amount it would receive under the distribution waterfall. PIPCA is the traditional safe harbor: liquidation distributions are made per positive Capital Account balances, requiring more rigid bookkeeping but providing clearer regulatory compliance.

These are mandatory under standard regulatory drafting. Uncheck only on advice of counsel.

Section 8 of 12

Tax Elections & Provisions

Configure tax classification, § 704(c) method election for contributed property, § 754 election, § 752 debt allocation method, BBA Partnership Representative, tax year, and tax distributions.

Most multi-member real estate LLCs are partnerships. S-corp election limits flexibility on classes of stock (one class limitation) and is rarely appropriate for real estate.

Section 704(c) — Contributed Property

Traditional: Ceiling rule limits allocation of book items to non-contributing Members to the extent of tax items; can leave non-contributors short. Curative: Permits offsetting allocations of other items to correct ceiling-rule distortions. Remedial: Permits notional allocations to overcome ceiling rule; recommended for institutional structures with substantial contributed property. Manager election preserves flexibility on a property-by-property basis.

Section 754 — Inside Basis Adjustment

§ 754 election permits the Company to adjust the inside basis of its assets upon transfer of an interest (§ 743) or distribution to a Member (§ 734). Mandatory under § 743 when a substantial built-in loss exists at the time of transfer.

Section 752 — Liability Allocation

Affects each Member’s share of nonrecourse debt for outside-basis and § 465 at-risk purposes, which in turn affects ability to deduct losses.

BBA Partnership Representative

Required under the centralized partnership audit regime (Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015) for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2018. The Partnership Representative has sole authority to bind the Company and all Members in IRS audit matters.

When the PR is an entity, a "Designated Individual" must be named per Reg. § 301.6223-1.

Push-out election shifts audit-year tax liability to the reviewed-year Members; without it, the Company pays an imputed underpayment that falls on current-year Members regardless of who held interests in the reviewed year.

Tax Year, Books & Records, Distributions

Tax distributions ensure Members have cash to pay tax on phantom (allocated but not distributed) income. Mandatory provisions are standard in institutional structures.

Rate applied to allocated taxable income for computing tax distribution amounts. Conservative practice uses the highest marginal rate of any Member to avoid under-distributing.

"Advance" treatment recoups tax distributions from subsequent waterfall distributions to that Member, preserving the economic deal. Standard practice.

Section 9 of 12

Transfers & Exit Mechanics

Configure restrictions on Membership Interest transfers, permitted-transferee categories, and exit mechanics (ROFO/ROFR, drag-along, tag-along, buy-sell).

Transfers to these categories are permitted without Member consent (subject to securities and tax compliance).

Section 10 of 12

Special Provisions

Optional articles for SPE / lender covenants, charging-order protection, fiduciary indemnification, confidentiality, restrictive covenants, dispute resolution, and Series LLC reservation.

Required by most commercial real-estate lenders for entities holding financed property. Independent Manager structure adds bankruptcy-remote characteristics for securitized debt.

Restrictive covenants in operating agreements are enforceable in Delaware to the extent of reasonable scope. Note state-law constraints if any Member resides in CA (enforceability of non-competes), MA, NY, etc.

Section 11 of 12

Securities Compliance

Select the securities-compliance level. The tool will generate the corresponding offering documents: at Level 0, a JV Securities Analysis Memorandum; at Levels 1–3, an Accredited Investor Questionnaire, Form D worksheet, and state Blue Sky notice; at Level 1, a lean Risk Disclosure Letter in lieu of a PPM; at Levels 2 and 3, a full Private Placement Memorandum; at Level 3, additional Investor Verification Documentation Standard and General Solicitation Compliance Memorandum.

Level 0 — for very small operating-member joint ventures among pre-existing-relationship principals where counsel reasonably concludes (under Howey and Williamson) that the membership interests are not "investment contracts." No Reg D filing; supported by counsel-authored Securities Analysis Memorandum. Level 1 — small-circle 506(b) raise with accredited investors who have pre-existing substantive relationships with the sponsor; self-certification; Risk Disclosure Letter in lieu of full PPM. Level 2 — institutional-quality 506(b) raise with full Private Placement Memorandum, but still no general solicitation. Level 3 — 506(c) general solicitation permitted; full PPM; reasonable-steps verification of accredited status required (Rule 506(c)(2)(ii)). Form D filing required within 15 days of first sale for all of Levels 1–3.

Aggregate capital being raised in the offering.

Levels 1 & 2: Reg D 506(b) permits unlimited accredited investors and up to 35 non-accredited sophisticated investors. Level 3: no investor count limit, but all must be verified accredited.

Offering should close within 12 months of first sale to remain within standard Form D framework.

Notice filings (typically Form D plus state form, with filing fee) are required in each state where an investor resides at the time of sale. Filing deadlines vary by state but most align with the federal 15-day Form D deadline. Generated Blue Sky notice template lists each state and applicable filing requirements.

Section 12 of 12

Review & Generate

Review the configuration and generate the draft Operating Agreement and companion documents. All documents are DRAFT, subject to attorney review and final issuance by Donovan Legal PLLC.

Important. All documents generated by this tool are drafts intended for attorney review and final issuance by Donovan Legal PLLC. Drafts are not legally effective until reviewed, finalized, and signed in accordance with the firm’s written engagement letter. RESERVE members should forward the generated documents to the firm for review against the specific deal facts and finalization before execution or reliance. Tax, allocation, and waterfall provisions involve fact-specific determinations that the firm verifies against the underlying economic deal, contributed property, lender requirements, and Members’ tax profiles before issuance. Reading or using this tool does not create an attorney–client relationship; an attorney–client relationship is created only by a signed engagement letter.